Now, there will be more to come and I will post them as I receive them. Also, the fansites will starting linking with each other so we can figure out exactly what's going on in the images once they are all put together. Stay tuned for further analysis!
Update: Got more pieces from Pieces of Eight Radio, Around the Spiral, A Pirates Portal, Paige Moonshade, Ditto Monster, Ambrose2Zeke as well as pics from @Pirate101 and have (poorly) pieced them together:
Here's the real one: